Banner Image 2X Targeted Targeted Policing

blockquote -

The Kinship Problem



Nationwide, forensic DNA labs have quietly been encountering troubling results when testing the newest computerized DNA analysis methods. Complex DNA mixtures give analysts real difficulty. To help with this, law enforcement recently began replacing human analysts with a computer program for some portions of that analysis. The software—generically called probabilistic genotyping—claims to reduce analytical error. Some labs are discovering, however, that the software can get a critical portion of cases wrong—badly wrong.

Take the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department’s Scientific Services Bureau. In their internal validation study of a probabilistic genotyping system, the Bureau created experiments testing DNA mixtures made up of first-order relatives. First-order relatives include an individual's parents, full siblings, and children. They did this specifically to figure out “how well the software can distinguish between closely-related individuals.” The results were abysmal.

Almost 90% of tested mixtures made up of 3 people or more produced results that falsely included a person the testers knew was not included in the mixture. In other words, the false positive error rate was 87%.

And those erroneous conclusions were not insignificant. Even in these false positive cases, the system claimed high confidence in its result. The Bureau warned: “Analysts should use caution when interpreting mixtures believed to be comprised of first-order relatives.”

And LA County is not alone. We’ve found eight other labs that encountered the same thing. On a scale where any value greater than 1 is inclusionary and larger magnitudes indicate elevating confidence levels, all of these labs discovered troubling false positives when relatives are involved:


DNA Crime Lab Highest Non-Related Highest Related Difference as a factor of
LA County Sherriff's Dept. 101 1015 100,000,000,000,000
Sacramento Cty. D.A.'s Crime Lab 101 1013 1,000,000,000,000
Palm Beach Cty. Sheriff's Office 106* 1017 100,000,000,000
Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Dept. 103 1013 10,000,000,000
Colorado Bureau of Investigation 102 1010 100,000,000
Jefferson Cty. Regional Crime Lab 102 109 10,000,000
DNA Labs International 102 107 100,000
Wisconsin State Crime Lab 102 107 100,000
Oregon State Police Portland Metro 104 106 100



The nine lab’s internal validation summaries discussed above are available NOW at the links below.





Visit BDS.org